Open Call Processes Reducing Barriers for Underrepresented Artists

Open calls are public invitations to submit work for an exhibition, residency, commission, or other opportunity, usually under stated eligibility and selection criteria. When designed to reduce barriers for underrepresented artists, they can widen who gets considered by making opportunities easier to find, simpler and cheaper to enter, and more transparent to judge. The need is substantial: the National Endowment for the Arts reported that in 2022, 52% of U.S. adults attended a visual or performing arts event, but participation and professional opportunities are not distributed equally. Accessible application design, equitable evaluation, targeted outreach, and fair compensation are practical ways to address gaps without lowering artistic standards.

Open-call design reduces barriers to artist participation

An open call is a competitive process in which an organization invites eligible applicants to submit proposals or examples of their work. Unlike invitation-only selection, an open call makes at least part of the opportunity publicly available. The term does not automatically mean that everyone has equal access: application costs, limited networks, inaccessible formats, unclear rules, and unpaid labor can still narrow the applicant pool.

The National Endowment for the Arts’ 2022 Survey of Public Participation in the Arts found that 52% of adults attended an arts event in person during the year, while 62% engaged with arts through digital media. Those figures describe public engagement, not employment or selection rates, but they show why organizations need to consider both physical and digital access when publicizing opportunities. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics also reports that artists’ work arrangements and earnings vary widely by occupation, underscoring the importance of avoiding unnecessary application expenses and unpaid work.

Accessible eligibility and application requirements

Accessible requirements are eligibility rules and submission instructions that are relevant to the opportunity, clearly explained, and feasible for applicants with different resources and access needs. A call can reduce friction by stating the fee, deadline and time zone, eligible locations and career stages, selection criteria, required materials, and expected time commitment in plain language. It should also offer a contact for accommodation requests and provide accessible digital documents.

The W3C Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) provide a recognized framework for making web content perceivable, operable, understandable, and robust. Applying those principles can help applicants who use screen readers, keyboard navigation, captions, or other assistive technologies. Organizations can also limit portfolio requirements to work that genuinely helps reviewers assess the proposal, accept alternative formats where practical, and avoid asking for extensive unpaid concept development before selection.

Fee-free and low-cost submission routes

A fee-free application removes a direct financial barrier; a low-cost process also considers expenses such as portfolio preparation, shipping, travel, internet access, and time away from paid work. Application fees may disproportionately deter artists with limited disposable income, especially when outcomes are uncertain or applicants must submit to several opportunities.

Organizations can waive fees, reimburse shipping, accept digital documentation, or provide a small stipend for shortlisted applicants asked to undertake substantial work. These measures should be stated before submission, rather than offered only after an applicant requests help. The distinction matters: an open invitation is not meaningfully accessible if participation depends on an artist’s ability to absorb costs.

Transparent evaluation makes open-call selection more equitable

Transparent evaluation is a selection process in which applicants can understand how decisions are made and organizations can explain how they applied published criteria. It does not require guaranteeing identical outcomes. It means assessing relevant artistic qualities consistently and reducing the influence of hidden expectations, personal connections, or assumptions about professional polish.

Research by sociologist Lauren Rivera, published in the American Sociological Review, found that evaluators in elite professional hiring often relied on cultural similarity and shared tastes when judging candidates. While that research examined professional services rather than arts open calls, it illustrates a broader risk: subjective assessments can reward familiarity as well as merit. Clear criteria and structured review help keep attention on the opportunity’s stated purpose.

Published criteria and consistent scoring

Published criteria identify the qualities reviewers will assess, such as artistic strength, relevance to a theme, feasibility, community benefit, or readiness for a commission. A useful call explains how those qualities relate to the opportunity and, where possible, how they are weighted. Reviewers can use a shared rubric and record brief reasons for their decisions.

Structured scoring does not eliminate judgment, which is central to arts selection. It makes judgment more accountable by prompting reviewers to assess comparable evidence against the same criteria. Organizations should also clarify whether they are selecting for a particular medium, location, experience level, or public-engagement goal, rather than leaving applicants to infer those priorities.

Jury diversity, conflicts of interest, and anonymized review

A diverse jury brings reviewers with different professional and community perspectives into the decision process. Diversity can include artistic discipline, geography, career stage, lived experience, and familiarity with different cultural contexts. The National Endowment for the Arts’ research on arts participation has documented differences in engagement across demographic groups; selection bodies should therefore consider whether their expertise reflects the communities the opportunity aims to serve.

Anonymized review, in which identifying details are withheld during an initial assessment, may reduce some forms of name- or affiliation-based bias. It is not suitable for every opportunity: an artist’s identity, community relationship, or track record may be relevant to a commission’s goals. Organizations can combine anonymized first-round review with conflict-of-interest disclosures, recusal rules, multiple reviewers, and a documented process for resolving score differences.

Outreach expands who hears about open calls

Outreach is the work of communicating an opportunity through channels that reach eligible artists beyond an organization’s established networks. Posting a call on an institutional website is necessary but may not be sufficient: artists who have fewer connections to galleries, universities, funders, or professional associations may never encounter it.

The Urban Institute’s research on arts organizations and equity emphasizes that organizational practices, networks, and access to resources shape participation in the arts. In practical terms, broad outreach means sharing calls with community-based arts groups, tribal and cultural organizations, disability arts networks, local libraries, artist-run spaces, and professional associations serving specific disciplines or regions. Partners should be given enough time and clear information to circulate the opportunity.

Community-led distribution and multilingual communication

Community-led distribution uses trusted local organizations and artist networks to reach people who may not follow major institutions. Translating essential information, offering plain-language summaries, and holding question-and-answer sessions can make an opportunity more understandable to applicants who use different languages or are unfamiliar with institutional application conventions.

Effective outreach is reciprocal rather than extractive. Organizations should avoid relying on community partners solely as unpaid advertising channels; they can provide outreach stipends, share the final results, and explain how community input influenced the call. These steps build trust and help identify barriers before the next application cycle.

Targeted calls and broad public access

A targeted open call is publicly advertised but designed for a defined group or purpose, such as artists from a particular region, disabled artists, emerging practitioners, or a specific medium. Targeting can direct resources to people historically excluded from an opportunity, while public criteria keep the process understandable and reviewable.

The design should explain why eligibility is limited and how the selection will work. Where funding conditions or applicable law affect eligibility, organizations should seek appropriate legal guidance. A targeted call should not substitute for examining broader institutional barriers, such as who serves on juries, whose work is collected, and whether selected artists receive equitable pay.

Fair compensation and clear terms improve participation

Fair compensation means paying artists for commissioned work and for substantial labor requested during the application or selection process. Clear terms explain the fee or honorarium, payment schedule, rights and licensing, production costs, travel support, and responsibilities before an artist commits. These details matter because an opportunity can be publicly accessible yet financially impractical.

The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Occupational Outlook Handbook describes artists’ employment as varied, with many workers self-employed or working on a project basis. For artists whose income depends on irregular commissions, unpaid proposals and unclear payment terms create real opportunity costs. Organizations should budget for artist fees, materials, access needs, and reasonable production expenses rather than treating exposure as a replacement for compensation.

Paid shortlisting and proportionate application labor

Paid shortlisting compensates finalists when an organization requests new concepts, mock-ups, interviews, site visits, or detailed project plans beyond a standard portfolio submission. The payment recognizes that application work has value, even for artists who are not ultimately selected.

A proportionate process asks only for the information needed at each stage. For example, an initial round can use a short statement and existing work samples, with a paid development stage for a smaller group of finalists. This staged approach reduces the burden on all applicants and helps organizations evaluate ideas without shifting project-development costs onto artists.

Rights, feedback, and timely decisions

Clear rights terms state how submitted images or proposals may be used, who owns the work, and whether the organization receives any license. Applicants should not be expected to transfer copyright simply by submitting. The call should also explain when applicants can expect a decision and whether unsuccessful applicants will receive feedback.

Timely decisions and concise feedback respect applicants’ labor and help them plan future work. Even when individual comments are not feasible, organizations can report the number of applications, selection stages, jury composition, and general reasons a proposal was or was not competitive. Such reporting turns an isolated call into a more accountable process.

Evaluation data helps organizations improve open calls

Evaluation data is information about who encountered, applied to, completed, and benefited from an opportunity, collected and used to improve the process. Organizations should distinguish between outreach reach, application completion, eligibility, selection, participation, and retention: a high number of submissions alone does not demonstrate equitable access.

The National Endowment for the Arts’ Survey of Public Participation in the Arts is an example of systematic data collection that helps researchers understand patterns in arts engagement. For an individual open call, relevant measures might include the number of applications by region, discipline, career stage, or voluntarily reported demographic characteristics, alongside completion rates and award outcomes. Small sample sizes and privacy risks require careful handling.

Applicant-pool and selection tracking

Applicant-pool tracking compares who applies with who advances and is selected. Voluntary, confidential demographic questions can help organizations identify where participation drops off, but applicants must be told why information is collected, who can see it, and how it will be protected. Data should not be used to make individual decisions unless that purpose is explicitly part of the published process.

A simple chart can compare the share of applicants, finalists, and awardees across relevant groups or regions. Such a chart should include the number of people in each group and avoid implying that a small sample proves a general pattern. Results are most useful when paired with feedback from applicants and community partners.

Continuous improvement and accountability

Continuous improvement means reviewing the process after each cycle and changing requirements that create unnecessary burdens. Organizations can ask applicants whether instructions were clear, whether the submission platform worked with assistive technology, how much time the application took, and whether the opportunity’s terms matched expectations.

Accountability requires assigning responsibility for follow-up. A staff member or committee can document changes, publish a short summary of lessons learned, and check whether those changes affect who applies and succeeds. This approach avoids treating inclusion as a one-time communications campaign and makes barrier reduction part of routine program management.

Conclusion: Open calls work best when access is designed in

Open calls can broaden opportunity when they combine accessible application requirements, transparent evaluation, outreach beyond familiar networks, fair compensation, and careful review of participation data. Publicity alone does not remove barriers: fees, inaccessible platforms, opaque criteria, unpaid labor, and weak communication can still exclude artists before their work is considered.

Arts organizations can take a practical next step by auditing one current call: simplify its requirements, publish a clear rubric, consult community partners, budget for finalist labor, and establish privacy-conscious measures for assessing results. Further reading from the National Endowment for the Arts, the W3C, the Urban Institute, and the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics can help organizations connect access principles with evidence and implementation.

Sources: National Endowment for the Arts, Survey of Public Participation in the Arts, https://www.arts.gov/impact/research/arts-data-profile-series/adp-31; U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook: Craft and Fine Artists, https://www.bls.gov/ooh/arts-and-design/craft-and-fine-artists.htm; World Wide Web Consortium, Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.2, https://www.w3.org/TR/WCAG22/; Rivera, Lauren A., “Hiring as Cultural Matching: The Case of Elite Professional Service Firms,” American Sociological Review, https://doi.org/10.1177/0003122412463213; Urban Institute, Creating Conditions for Artists to Thrive: An Evaluation of the Supporting Diverse Arts Spaces Initiative, https://www.urban.org/research/publication/creating-conditions-artists-thrive-evaluation-supporting-diverse-arts-spaces-initiative.

Categories: Art